GAMING
Valve Won’t Gatekeep AI as Indies Hide Steam Demos
Valve will not restrict AI tools on Steam, even as clone fears push indie studios to hide public demos from Next Fest.
Valve told indie developers on October 27 it will not restrict AI tools on Steam, even as studios pull public demos to stop clones. Tom Giardino and Marc Wilkinson of the Steam business team took that line at Steam Indie Connect in Seoul, a closed Q&A co-hosted with the Busan Indie Connect Festival and Korea’s content agency KOCCA.
Giardino said Valve does not want to pick which tools a studio may use. In the same month, the team behind Moonlighter moved its next game’s playtest off Steam.
Valve Told Korean Indies It Will Not Police AI Tools
A developer in the room described emails that threatened to copy a game with AI and ship it first unless the original team paid. The wording that circulated was blunt: “If you don’t pay, we’ll clone your game with AI and release it first.” Giardino said it was the first he had heard of those cases. He called the threats a matter for police, then invited studios to file them with Valve as well.
We don’t want to be gatekeepers telling developers which tools they should or shouldn’t use.
Tom Giardino, Steam Business, Steam Indie Connect
“If you report such cases to us, we want to look into them further and help in whatever way we can,” he said. He also argued that cloning predates generative models, and that AI has mainly sped up a habit that used to take longer: spotting a hook during a festival and rushing out a lookalike.
His practical advice was not a new store rule. Build a player base that trusts you, then keep shipping features a copy cannot fake overnight. “Rather than relying on a single mechanic that someone can easily copy, you need to keep growing your game by adding features, personality, and creativity that stem from your own perspective,” Giardino said.
Wilkinson handled the other complaint in the room, which was Steam Next Fest itself. For the first two days, he said, the store shows participating games in a near-random mix so every demo gets a chance to be seen. After that, personal recommendations take over. “We recognize that the trade-off is some low-quality games get exposed,” he said. “We are fully aware of the situation, and a significant number of people are thinking about how to solve this problem.”
Giardino closed the policy door he had opened. “We don’t think we’re perfect and there’s plenty of room for improvement,” he said. “Rather than limiting developer access, making Steam a smarter and more dynamic platform is the starting point of our philosophy.” He told the room that three years earlier he had been recruiting for a Next Fest of 50 or 100 games. The field is now in the thousands. He called it the pendulum swinging the other way.
The ReVamp Playtest That Left Steam
Digital Sun, the Valencia studio known for Moonlighter and Cataclismo, had opened Steam sign-ups for a public playtest of ReVamp, a “tower defensevania” due in March 2027. On October 19 it reversed course. Tens of thousands of players had already requested access. The studio decided a wide Steam build, months before launch, was too easy to rip apart and republish.
The public post was short. “We’ve been concerned by recent news of games being reverse-engineered, cloned and published before the original is even out,” Digital Sun wrote. “With launch still months away, a large public build of ReVamp felt like too big a risk.” A smaller Discord test was set for October 29, with a public Steam run hoped for around January.
For anyone who'd still like a chance to play this year, the Discord playtest starts October 29:https://t.co/9i2ILhsARK
— Digital Sun ✨ Wishlist ReVamp! (@DigitalSunGames) October 19, 2026
Marketing manager Israel Mallén put the same fear in plainer terms. “With launch still months away, sharing a build with tens of thousands of players feels like too big a risk,” he said. The studio has been shipping games for a decade. “We’ve been making games like Moonlighter and Cataclismo for a decade, and we’d never felt this kind of worry about sharing our games with the community before,” Mallén said. “If you can’t show your game to the world without fearing it’ll be cloned, something’s broken.”
Alliance Arts made a similar call during the same Next Fest window. It cancelled the planned demo of Drunken Goddess Reflux after concluding that the build could be imitated with AI or other tools and released before the real game. Showing work early is how small teams find an audience. It is also how a copycat gets a finished-looking product for the price of a download.
Steam Has Logged 22,743 Releases in 2026
The store’s raw volume makes that trade feel worse. Tracker 22,743 games already released in 2026, with November and December still to come, according to SteamDB. That is already 1,519 more than the 21,224 that landed in all of 2025.
STEAM RELEASES BY YEAR
| Year | Games released |
|---|---|
| 2017 (Steam Direct begins) | 6,925 |
| 2020 | 9,632 |
| 2023 | 14,016 |
| 2025 | 21,224 |
| 2026 (year to date) | 22,743 |
Most of those titles will never trouble a bestseller chart. They still occupy the same store, the same search box, and the same festival page as the next small game that might actually catch on. Giardino’s “keep updating” advice is free to give. It is a tax on the team that already shipped the original.
Why Next Fest Starts With a Random Shuffle
Steam Next Fest opens with two days of near-random exposure so every demo can be seen, then switches to personal recommendations based on what a user plays and buys. Wilkinson said wishlists are a weak visibility signal next to actual purchases and playtime, and that Valve has been talking up a Wishlist Data API and a Personalized Calendar as extra discovery tools. The cost of the early shuffle, he admitted, is that low-quality builds get the same opening window as everyone else.
Market data firm Alinea Analytics counted 7,300 demos at October’s Next Fest, up from about 4,400 in June, a 66% jump in one cycle. Alinea also put the October field at more than twice the year-earlier event and about ten times the October 2022 edition. That is the “fair shot” working as designed, and it is the same design that dumps a user into a grid of thousands of builds before the store knows what they like.
HOW NEXT FEST DECIDES WHAT YOU SEE
- Days one and two: Recommendations run close to random, so a new demo can appear beside a known one.
- After that: The store tilts toward games a user is more likely to play, using purchases and playtime more than wishlists.
- The trade: Wilkinson said Valve knows some low-quality games get that early slot, and that staff are working on the mess.
Owners keep saying the first day looks like junk and the later days look better. That is not a glitch in the pitch Wilkinson gave. It is the pitch. The unknown studio Next Fest was built to help now shares those 48 hours with anyone who can export a demo, including teams that will not be around to patch it.
The $100 Door That Opened in 2017
Valve has been here before, with different tools and the same sentence. When Steam Direct replaced Greenlight on June 13, 2017, the company chose a low cash barrier and promised the store would get better at sorting what came through it.
THE OPEN-DOOR YEARS
- June 13, 2017: Steam Direct goes live with a recoupable $100 fee per game, returned after $1,000 in store or in-app sales, plus a short check that a build matches its page and is not malware.
- Same post, 2017: Valve says it is rewriting its recommendation engine and expects a higher submission rate than Greenlight, while hoping a class of “game-shaped objects” will not be worth even $100.
- January 2024 into 2026: Steam adds, then tightens, a generative-AI disclosure on the Content Survey rather than a ban on the tools.
- October 27, 2026: Giardino restates the Direct-era line: do not limit who can ship, make the store smarter.
The 2017 blog is almost a template for the Seoul Q&A. Valve did not want a heavy certification process. It wanted paperwork, a modest fee, and a rec engine. Releases rose from 6,925 in Direct’s first year to 22,743 this year with two months left. The $100 check still exists. AI dropped the cost of filling the other 23 hours in a day.
Steam Already Collects AI Disclosures on Every Page
The company is not ignoring AI on paper. Before a game can go up for review, Steamworks makes the developer complete a Content Survey with three parts: general content, mature content, and generative AI. The generative AI section of the Content Survey asks whether shipped art, sound, writing, or live in-game generation used those tools, and it puts much of that answer on the store page.
Valve’s own wording draws a line. “Efficiency gains through the use of these tools is not the focus of this section,” the docs say. “Instead, it is concerned with the use of AI in creating content that ships with your game, and is consumed by players.” Coding assistants sit on one side of that line. Capsule art, voices, and in-game text sit on the other. Live generation also needs a note on the guardrails meant to stop illegal output.
That is not a filter. Players can read a disclosure if they open a page. They cannot, from the new-releases list, hide everything that carries one. Review still checks that a game is legal, matches its marketing, and is not malware. It does not ask whether the demo is a clone of someone else’s Next Fest build. For copied assets, Valve’s documented path is Steam’s copyright infringement notice form, which only helps if you already know you were copied and can prove it.
What Indie Studios Want From Steam Playtests
Mallén’s ask was narrower than a tool ban, and it sits inside Steam’s existing playtest system. Steam can already limit a playtest by country. It cannot, he said, let a studio tell a ten-year-old account with a purchase history apart from a fresh profile created only to grab the build. He wanted extra checks on who gets a pre-release copy: account age, playtime, review history. Digital Sun can do that by hand on Discord. It cannot do it at Steam scale.
THE ACCESS CHECKS STUDIOS SAY THEY LACK
- Account age: A brand-new profile is the cheapest way to join a public playtest and walk away with the files.
- Purchase and play history: A user who already buys and finishes games is a different risk than a throwaway login.
- Review history: A short public record is a weak signal, but it is more than Steam currently offers for a closed build.
Giardino’s answer to clones was community plus patches. That only works if the original is allowed to be seen first, and if the people who see it are not the ones racing to republish it. Wilkinson’s answer to Next Fest was a smarter store, not a smaller door. The Seoul session left both ideas on the table and added no new lock.
On October 29, ReVamp’s first testers were set to come in through Discord waves instead of a Steam queue. Valve’s line did not move with them. The store will still take the next demo from anyone who can pay $100 and fill out the survey, and Next Fest will still spend two days showing that pile at random.
-
AUTO3 months agoThe Last Manual V-12 Lamborghini Cannot Come to America
-
NEWS3 months agoRune Bets on Hillerød for His Achilles Comeback
-
BUSINESS3 months agoJBS’s Pilgrim’s Pride Bid Still Needs the 18 Percent
-
NEWS3 months agoMurphy Defends a British Open Title Nobody Keeps
-
NEWS3 months agoPermafrost Thaw Runs Fastest in Mountains, Not Arctic Soils
-
BUSINESS3 months agoInfluencer Investors Trade Cash Fees for Illiquid Equity
-
NEWS3 months agoThe Roman Space Telescope Flies After Four Budget Fights
-
BUSINESS3 months agoRubicon Research Q1 Tests Its Specialty Pharma Bet
